| 2016 | James L. Oliver | Walt Disney | Flint |
| 2015 | Joshua R. Lampar | Roseville | Flint |
| 2014 | Maxwell G. Jenkins | Clifford C. Reeves | Flint |
| 2013 | Maxwell G. Jenkins | Clifford C. Reeves | Big Rapids |
| 2012 | Zachary A. Krawczyk | Dearborn | Big Rapids |
| 2011 | Zachary A. Krawczyk | Dearborn | Big Rapids |
| 2010 | Christopher Eggert | Roseville | Big Rapids |
| 2009 | David A. Bodine | Walt Disney | Lansing |
| 2008 | Matthew J. Lambka | Roseville | Lansing |
| 2007 | Kyle Cherwinski | Clio | Lansing |
| 2006 | Matthew L. Rizzo | Livingston County | Lansing |
| 2005 | Daniel Myers | Livingston County | Lansing |
| 2004 | Steven A. McKay | Roseville | Lansing |
| 2003 | Jason M. McClanahan | Livingston County | Van Dyke Park |
| 2002 | James W. Talbot | Roseville | Big Rapids |
| 2001 | Randy A. Searles, II | Lansing | Big Rapids |
| 2000 | Edward W. Taylor, Jr. | Dearborn | Big Rapids |
| 1999 | Ryan E. Binkley | Clio | Big Rapids |
| 1998 | Matthew J. Burnett | Clifford C. Reeves | Big Rapids |
| 1997 | Alan R. Zirkle | George Washington | Big Rapids |
| 1996 | James C. McConnell, Jr. | Grand Rapids | Big Rapids |
| 1995 | Derek C. Thamarus | Clifford C. Reeves | Big Rapids |
| 1994 | Matthew J. Tomecek | Huron Valley | Big Rapids |
| 1993 | William C. Meyer | George Washington | Big Rapids |
| 1992 | Michael J. Baird | Commerce | Big Rapids |
| 1991 | Matthew R. Shelton | George Washington | Lansing |
| 1990 | Mark E. Smiley | Lansing | Central Michigan University |
| 1989 | Donald D. Dombrow, Jr. | Acacia | Central Michigan University |
| 1988 | Michael K. Blankinship | Swartz Creek | Western Michigan University |
| 1987 | Scott W. Greenlee | Grand Rapids | Ferris State University |
| 1986 | James L. Carey | Architect | Michigan State University |
| 1985 | Timothy C. Berkley | Roseville | Central Michigan University |
| 1984 | William R. Wells | Farmington | Central Michigan University |
| 1983 | Jon P. Cook | Battle Creek | Central Michigan University |
| 1982 | Jonathan D. White | Belleville | Central Michigan University |
| 1981 | William R. Blaker | Roseville | Central Michigan University |
| 1980 | Michael R. Grove | Livingston County | Central Michigan University |
| 1979 | Mark A. Furdero | Grandville | Central Michigan University |
| 1978 | James J. Hawreluk | Garden City | Central Michigan University |
| 1977 | Nicholas H. Palaian | Rochester | Michigan State University |
| 1976 | Michael J. Gross | Acacia | Michigan State University |
| 1975 | Edward W. Fisher | Jackson | Central Michigan University |
| 1974 | Charles L. Harwell | Farmington | Central Michigan University |
| 1973 | Robert E. Hager | Lansing | Ferris State University |
| 1972 | D. Christopher Pedigo | Ferndale | Ferris State University |
| 1971 | Mark S. Olson | Lansing | Grand Rapids |
| 1970 | Gary H. Lukovich | Port Huron | Grand Rapids |
| 1969 | Gerald E. Smith | Coldwater ? Premier | Lansing |
| 1968 | Duwain M. Hunt | Clifford C. Reeves | Lansing |
| 1967 | Larry M. Dillon | Battle Creek | Lansing |
| 1966 | Phillip R. Pearce | East Lansing | Grand Rapids |
| 1965 | Roderick S. Coy | Shiawassee | Grand Rapids |
| 1964 | Gay N. Price | Redford | Grand Rapids |
| 1963 | Robert A. Koch | Dearborn | Bay City |
| 1962 | Ronald W. Hubbs | Plymouth | Northern Michigan University |
| 1961 | John P. Fuhrmann | Newaygo County | Grand Rapids |
| 1960 | William L. Ballard | Flint | Traverse City |
| 1959 | Wayne K. North | Fellowship | Jackson |
| 1958 | Harvey M. Workman, Jr. | Muskegon | Bay City |
| 1957 | Douglas C. Fosth | Royal Oak | Bay City |
| 1956 | Maxe A. Obermeyer | Ypsilanti | Grand Rapids |
| 1955 | Richard A. Huebler | Plymouth | Detroit |
| 1954 | Willis W. Andrews | Muskegon | Flint |
| 1953 | H. Don Cameron | George Washington | Lansing |
| 1952 | Keith W. Spence | Ionic | No Records |
| 1951 | Robert W. Kerry | Flint | No Records |
| 1950 | Kenneth W. Goodrich | Lansing | No Records |
| 1949 | Robert Frey | Wyandotte | No Records |
| 1948 | No Records | No Records | No Records |
| 1947 | No Records | No Records | No Records |
| 1946 | No Records | No Records | No Records |
| 1945 | No Records | No Records | No Records |
| 1944 | Robert Menne | Bay City | No Records |
| 1943 | Ralph Ridenour | Ypsilanti | No Records |
| 1942 | Allistair Dunn | Detroit Zion | No Records |
| 1941 | George Fegert | Bay City | No Records |
| 1940 | Earle W. Mott, Jr. | Loyalty | No Records |
| 1939 | Earle W. Mott, Jr. | Loyalt | Camp Te-Tonk-Ah |
| 1938 | John W. Goff, Jr. | Jackson | No Records |
| 1937 | Ray Fisher | Loyalty | No Records |
| 1936 | Ray Fisher | Loyalty | No Records |
| 1935 | Harold Schumacher | Highland Park | No Records |
| 1934 | No Records | No Records | No Records |
| 1933 | No Records | No Records | No Records |
| 1932 | No Records | No Records | No Records |
| 1931 | No Records | No Records | No Records |
| 1930 | No Records | No Records | No Records |
| 1929 | No Records | No Records | No Records |
| 1928 | No Records | No Records | No Records |
| 1927 | No Records | No Records | No Records |
| 1926 | No Records | No Records | No Records |
| 1925 | John Rademaker, Jr. | Manistee | No Records |
| 1924 | Stiles L. Brown | Grand Rapids | Grand Rapids |
